Join me today as I share my impressions of the Aladino Habano Vintage Selection Rothschild.
It’s not often that I write a review after smoking more than one cigar of a kind. Of course, I do revisit cigars from time to time, and those experiences have taught me more than once just how misleading first impressions can be. Although that’s not always the case. Sometimes, when I return to a cigar I’ve reviewed before, I find myself agreeing with every word I wrote and wouldn’t hesitate to stand by my original assessment. Other times, I wonder how I could have written some of those things in the first place. I suppose that’s perfectly natural. After all, I’m writing about my own subjective impressions, and those can be influenced by countless factors. This time, however, my review is based on three examples of the same cigar, all smoked within a relatively short period of time.
So, how did the Aladino Vintage Selection Rothschild perform? Let’s find out.

Aladino Habano Vintage Selection Rothschild
The Aladino Vintage Selection line was introduced relatively recently, in 2020, initially with just one vitola: the Rothschild. There’s an interesting story behind this decision, one I heard personally from Justo Eiroa. Apparently, when the family was considering introducing a new cigar line, Justo, Julio Eiroa’s son, suggested that they should follow market trends and focus on larger formats. His father responded by asking him what size cigar he was smoking at that very moment. When Justo replied that it was a Rothschild, Julio simply said that if he enjoyed that size, then that was exactly the format they would produce.
What truly sets these cigars apart is the amount of time they spent aging after being rolled. The original cigars were produced in 2015-2016, meaning they had been resting and maturing for approximately five years before finally making their market debut. This is an important detail, as it shows that the word „Vintage” in the line’s name is far more than just a marketing gimmick.
The Aladino Vintage Selection is a Honduran puro, made entirely from tobacco grown in Honduras. The wrapper is Honduran Habano, while both the binder and filler consist of Authentic Corojo tobacco cultivated on the Eiroa family’s own farms.
The line is currently available in three vitolas:
- Rothschild (4 1/2 × 48),
- Toro (6 × 50),
- Elegante (7 × 38).
In today’s review, I’ll be sharing my impressions of the smallest of the three, the Rothschild.

A Few Technical Notes
The cigar comes in a Rothschild vitola, measuring 4 1/2 inches (11.43 cm) in length with a ring gauge of 48. In the hand, it actually feels a little larger than its dimensions might suggest, more like a Robusto than a smaller format.
The wrapper is neither particularly light nor dark, but certainly attractive. The cigar is adorned with a band featuring shades of gold, beige, and brown, with the name of the line appearing just below the Aladino logo.
Overall, the cigar makes a very good first impression, although I can’t help thinking that it would look just as good without the additional lettering identifying the line. Sometimes, less is more.
The Cut
I decided to open the cigar with a straight cutter. I’ve noticed that this has become my go-to method lately. It seems my days of experimenting are behind me, and I’ve settled on a tried-and-true approach that suits me just fine.
Before making the cut, however, I take a moment to prepare my senses. The cigar gives off a pleasant aroma, with a delicate sweetness accompanied by notes of cedar. Time for the cut.
The draw is perfect! Cedar dominates the cold draw, although there’s something else in the background. It reminds me of a fresh, minty note, which comes as quite a surprise.
The Light
I give the foot a thorough toast with a jet flame lighter before lighting the cigar with a series of short, gentle puffs. I then set it aside for a moment to let it settle before beginning the tasting.
Right from the start, I’m greeted by a wave of creaminess, accompanied by subtle woody notes. There’s also a certain sweetness to the overall profile. As the cigar progresses, I get the impression that a hint of cocoa makes an appearance as well.
The final stretch brings earthy and leathery notes to the forefront, although the earthiness makes its presence known earlier, adding depth to the blend. The leather remains subtle and never becomes overpowering. Overall, the composition is thoroughly enjoyable, with a remarkably smooth character.
Strength & Body
The cigar’s strength stays firmly in the medium range.
Aroma & Smoke
The cigar produces a generous amount of aromatic smoke, with sweet, creamy notes taking center stage and a faint hint of wood lingering in the background.
Construction & Burn
The cigar burns remarkably evenly, while the ash holds together very well.

Final Thoughts on Aladino Habano Vintage Selection Rothschild
A very enjoyable cigar. One I’d happily revisit. I think it would be worth keeping a few on hand for those occasions when there’s time for a slightly shorter smoke, perhaps in the morning with a cup of coffee.
I had the pleasure of smoking three of these cigars before writing this review, and this time, I didn’t notice any significant differences compared to my first experience. What stands out most is the remarkably smooth flavor profile and relatively mild strength.
Although I’ve come to realize that Habano wrappers aren’t usually my favorite, everything comes together beautifully in this particular blend. And knowing the story behind the creation of the line and this specific vitola, I think I’d be perfectly happy sticking with the Rothschild without even exploring the other sizes in the Vintage Selection lineup.
Highly recommended.
This cigar review was made possible thanks to the efforts of Szymon Kwiatkowski of Premium Cigars.
If you enjoyed reading this, let me know! Drop a comment or share the post – every bit of support helps others discover my cigar reviews and smoking tips. If you prefer to listen, I co-host a podcast with Piotr Siwiński called „Spotkanie z Dymem” („A Meeting with Smoke”) – currently in Polish, though who knows what the future holds? You can also find me on Instagram, where I share a slice of my cigar life – and a bit more. I always welcome a good conversation. That’s how great connections start – and they often go far beyond just cigars.
Stay smoky!
Mateusz Krzywiecki, @mateusz.krzywiecki, Polski Aficionado, @polskiaficionado



